STOP! This is illegal. You may be monitored and fined.
Did that get your attention? Good. Because according to a new UNLV study, this phrasing coupled with a graphic of a computer and download symbol with a prohibitive slash is the most effective way to stop music piracy.
The research, borne out of dissertation work by UNLV psychology instructor Joanne Ullman, tested 220 college undergraduates’ reactions to more than 70 symbols, action words, and warning phrases. Among the findings:
- Signal words conveying the presence of risk (IMPORTANT and STOP) received higher perceived effectiveness ratings than NOTICE.
- An icon depicting the illegality of uploading copyrighted music scored less effective.
- Regarding warning messages, researchers evaluated them to be sure they could be understood with a literacy level of 5th grade or lower. They initially hypothesized that the threat of fines alone was most likely to scare off illegal downloaders. But they were surprised to find that people are equally leery of being monitored by unknown entities — and pairing the repercussions proved most effective.
“For some individuals, privacy may be just as important as a pecuniary consequence,” researchers wrote in their paper, which was published and presented last month during the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 2018 Annual Meeting. “Of course, the combination of both would heighten the potential consequence.”
Currently, the Copyright Act allows damages of $750 up to $150,000 per infringement. Moreover, under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, internet service providers can disable repeat offenders’ web access.
“Technically, there’s no music out there that’s free,” Ullman said, referencing the 2018 Music Modernization Act which for the first time enacts federal laws — that will supersede a vague, contradictory, confusing patchwork of state laws protecting sound recordings — and allow fully-protected music to enter public domain beginning in 2022. She noted that even the “Happy Birthday” song, protected under the vague older laws, didn’t enter public domain until 2016 under a judge’s ruling; previously, she said, movies and restaurants were among entities that would create their own version or avoid using the song altogether to avoid legal battles surrounding copyright infringement.
Ullman says that, similar to jaywalking, music copyright laws are not regulated across the board and therefore could be subject to selective enforcement. And that could become a problem for the United States, which produces and distributes the most music in the world.
Throughout history, Ullman said, copyright issues have become an issue whenever there’s been modernization; for example, laws had to be created to protect works reproduced after the printing press was invented. “There might be a correlation between our economic condition and how strict (the government or music companies) are with intellectual property. Economic recessions may actually lead to more stringent enforcement with respect to copyright laws,” she said.
With respect to the effectiveness of music piracy warnings, Ullman said we all have different levels of risk aversions because of our personality or profession.
“I doubt these symbols will get someone to suddenly change their mind and say, ‘Piracy is bad’, “ she said. “But at least being reminded that if you download something illegally you may be monitored or fined, we can think about our behavior and make thoughtful decisions. That’s especially important in the online world where we’re so task-focused; the pictorial can almost immediately remind you — you don’t even have to read anything — and make you say, ‘I should think before I act’.”